An hour ago I closed a questiona question as a duplicate of an, in my opinion appropriate, generic questionan, in my opinion appropriate, generic question. Two gold badge holders have since expressed disagreement with my decision, and the question has since gone thru a full reopen/reclose cycle.
There is always room for interpretation, and because I have a history of also fighting everything that smells of rep farming, I should not rule out the possibility that I have crossed some line myself in an overzealous effort to find more duplicates.
Another example of a question I closed as a duplicate yesterdayAnother example of a question I closed as a duplicate yesterday. This time there has been one gold badge owner in disagreement, and the question was reopened overnight (in my timezone of GMT+2), but has since been reclosed by another gold-badge owner. In my opinion the answers to the duplicate targetthe duplicate target cover this question more than adequately. The late parts in Arturo's answer feel particularly fitting.
So time to collect some feedback from you.
How close a match to a question from the list of generalizations of commonly asked questions do I/we need to instaclose a new incarnation?