2 deleted 339 characters in body
source | link

What is MSE not?

To understand what something is, we must also understand what it is not. Some things are obvious: MSE is not a place for Harry Potter questions, nor is it a place to advertise the latest summer fashion trends.

I further assert:

  • MSE is not a classroom
  • MSE is not a textbook
    • Corollary: MSE is not a solutions manual
  • MSE is not a factory

And also due to the actual implementation of SE:

  • MSE is not a math chatroom
  • MSE is not a math forum

While some amount of discussion is possible and productive, the site really isn't well designed for that type of interaction.

So what is MSE?

I agree with the option

Math.SE is a place to do math (at all levels), asking questions as they arise and helping others with theirs when we can.

However, "learning and teaching" already fits into this description; questions arise in the process of learning, and answering questions gives people an opportunity to teach others how to solve problems and write short expository articles on the topic asked.

Goals versus effects.

It's important to recognize the difference between the goal of a policy and the actual effects a policy will have. In fact, the actual intent of a policy is mostly irrelevant (but ideally is correlated) to its actual merits and demerits, and it is the latter qualities upon which it must be judged.

What is MSE not?

To understand what something is, we must also understand what it is not. Some things are obvious: MSE is not a place for Harry Potter questions, nor is it a place to advertise the latest summer fashion trends.

I further assert:

  • MSE is not a classroom
  • MSE is not a textbook
    • Corollary: MSE is not a solutions manual
  • MSE is not a factory

And also due to the actual implementation of SE:

  • MSE is not a math chatroom
  • MSE is not a math forum

While some amount of discussion is possible and productive, the site really isn't well designed for that type of interaction.

So what is MSE?

I agree with the option

Math.SE is a place to do math (at all levels), asking questions as they arise and helping others with theirs when we can.

However, "learning and teaching" already fits into this description; questions arise in the process of learning, and answering questions gives people an opportunity to teach others how to solve problems and write short expository articles on the topic asked.

Goals versus effects.

It's important to recognize the difference between the goal of a policy and the actual effects a policy will have. In fact, the actual intent of a policy is mostly irrelevant (but ideally is correlated) to its actual merits and demerits, and it is the latter qualities upon which it must be judged.

What is MSE not?

To understand what something is, we must also understand what it is not. Some things are obvious: MSE is not a place for Harry Potter questions, nor is it a place to advertise the latest summer fashion trends.

I further assert:

  • MSE is not a classroom
  • MSE is not a textbook
    • Corollary: MSE is not a solutions manual
  • MSE is not a factory

And also due to the actual implementation of SE:

  • MSE is not a math chatroom
  • MSE is not a math forum

While some amount of discussion is possible and productive, the site really isn't well designed for that type of interaction.

So what is MSE?

I agree with the option

Math.SE is a place to do math (at all levels), asking questions as they arise and helping others with theirs when we can.

However, "learning and teaching" already fits into this description; questions arise in the process of learning, and answering questions gives people an opportunity to teach others how to solve problems and write short expository articles on the topic asked.

1
source | link

What is MSE not?

To understand what something is, we must also understand what it is not. Some things are obvious: MSE is not a place for Harry Potter questions, nor is it a place to advertise the latest summer fashion trends.

I further assert:

  • MSE is not a classroom
  • MSE is not a textbook
    • Corollary: MSE is not a solutions manual
  • MSE is not a factory

And also due to the actual implementation of SE:

  • MSE is not a math chatroom
  • MSE is not a math forum

While some amount of discussion is possible and productive, the site really isn't well designed for that type of interaction.

So what is MSE?

I agree with the option

Math.SE is a place to do math (at all levels), asking questions as they arise and helping others with theirs when we can.

However, "learning and teaching" already fits into this description; questions arise in the process of learning, and answering questions gives people an opportunity to teach others how to solve problems and write short expository articles on the topic asked.

Goals versus effects.

It's important to recognize the difference between the goal of a policy and the actual effects a policy will have. In fact, the actual intent of a policy is mostly irrelevant (but ideally is correlated) to its actual merits and demerits, and it is the latter qualities upon which it must be judged.