# Why this body does not qualify as a valid maths question?

"Given $\frac r s$, with $r, s \in \mathbb N$. Is there an expression to obtain the values for $x, y, u, v \in \mathbb N$, where $\frac x y$ and $\frac u v$ are irreducible, such that $\frac a b = \frac x y + \frac u v$ ?"

Gosh! Here, it keeps saying it: "This question body does not meet our quality standards. Please make sure that it completely describes your problem - including what you have already tried - and is written using proper grammar."

Note: After adding the second paragraph, finally it went trough...

• I think support tag should be changed as discussion. – choco_addicted Jun 1 '16 at 11:40
• Done, @choco_addicted. Is it really such a bad question? Can't really grasp the meaning of the "-5" that it shows now... I couldn't send my question to the math forum, and it made all the sense. – nightcod3r Jun 2 '16 at 5:43
• As a human being reading your question, I am struck by the initial mention of $r,s$ as natural numbers but never mentioned again. Possibly they are the intended $a,b$? More than just clearing up that notational confusion should be done to make your Readers comfortable with replying in a useful manner. You should indicate what your interest and involvement with the problem is, however briefly, so that no one wastes time explaining matters you already explored or understood. – hardmath Jun 2 '16 at 16:25