According to Wikipedia and my knowledge, mathematical physics is a branch of math and use advanced mathematical methods to deal with physical problems, mathematical methods like functional analysis (especially operator algebra, spectral theory), algebraic topology, algebraic geometry, Riemannian geometry and geometrical analysis, complex geometry and Kahler manifolds etc.
As far as I'm concerned, only calculation and derivation with physical background but without using mathematical methods, should be taggedphysics instead of mathematical-physics, and questions about physical field should not be tagged field-theory which is a branch of abstract algebra in MSE.
However, I do feel confused (and a little disappointed) when the following edits were rejected:
Are there any explanation for these rejected edits? And are there any suggestions to avoid this?
Some rejection update when I tried to edit some high-vote question with mathematical-physics to decrease misunderstanding.
Although some of my edits were rejected by some users repeatedly, I don't mean to accuse or blame anyone, just want to make some contribution to this community by making question with mathematical-physics tagged correctly, and know how to improve myself.
Thanks for your kindly discussion.
These edits above were all rejected by Saad in less than 1 minute, which makes me doubt if my (and other users') edits were treated seriously, or just simply rejected for convenience. And I don't think that's a polite and friendly manner to do so.
tqft and topological-quantum-field-theory should be suggested synonyms, but tqft has few users and questions. This was discussed here and here. So I decided to manually change [tqft] to [topological-quantum-field-theory]. However, these edits were all rejected by Saad again.