Recently, a large controversy has started within the Minecraft fanbase, regarding the speedrunner Dream, and claims of him possibly cheating by altering probabilities for certain random events within the game, to get more consistent, and better times. The majority of this argument had been centered around the statistics of the probabilities, after Dream hired a statistician to argue that the math was wrong, and then, in the future, another statistician wrote a paper arguing that that math was wrong. There have been multiple threads on sites like reddit, with users pitching in their opinions, and their understanding of the mathematics. However, not being a reddit user, I would be interested in posting a similar discussion type question on the Math SE, asking for interpretations and solutions for purely the mathematics involved - everyone seems to be solving it in a different way.
Would a discussion-type question about this be on-topic for Math SE, or must it be narrowed down to a specific question?
A reminder that I am not asking whether the topic itself would be on-topic - it is inarguably about statistics and mathematics. I am just asking if the format of a discussion would be acceptable in this case, or whether it should be done in a different way.