36

[...] would it be considered bad form if I were to upvote it (as they would receive a random notification for an answer they wrote a few years ago and most likely forgot)? It's good form to up-vote good content one comes across. Moreover, I think for many it is rather a nice experience to be reminded by an up-vote of an old post. It shows that the content ...


26

The whole point of stack exchange is to build a high quality collection of questions and answers for a given subject. If you think of things in these terms, it is irrelevant how old a question is. If you can improve the corpora with a better answer, add it.


15

Could you be a bit more specific about the situation in which you expect to get a comment. In the current revision you write: "I do not get a notification when someone writes a comment under an answer, where I commented too." AFAICT that is exactly how this is supposed to work - with one notable exception that if you and the OP are the only users ...


14

Answering bumps the question but (I think) only for those who have clicked the "active" option, not for those who are using "recent". Commenting notifies the person who posted the question. Commenting on an answer also notifies the person who posted the answer. Commenting may also notify a few others who have contributed to the question/answer – see the ...


13

Users with 10,000 rep or more can see deleted answers (and moderators, although in practice they likely have more than 10,000 rep anyway). One way to make deleted answers less prominent is to edit them to say "This answer was deleted by the user", or something similar. The edit history is also visible to 10,000+ rep users, but the edit hides the old ...


11

I disagree with this proposal. Personally, I do not see my participation in Math.SE as an invitation for everyone to ping me with their questions. A user leaving an off-topic comment to draw my attention to their question goes on my personal "ignore" list at once. (Unofficially; there is no built-in ignore list.) Tagging questions properly is the best way ...


10

Just added today... the "follow" feature.


8

We had problems with a datacenter test that left our caching layer in a partially broken state. All issues should now be resolved. See also https://meta.stackoverflow.com/questions/268957/topbar-notifications-dont-go-away


8

I believe it is not literally by mistake, but it will likely be changed. See Please don't red alert me for queues I've handled for not the exact same matter but something related (it's about users that at the moment cannot review), where it says that several improvements are planned.


8

It is not possible to contact users that vote to close your questions, especially not before the vote took effect. It is possible to contact users that cast a binding vote on your question (note that the vote needs to be the only vote that created the effect), that is a moderator or a user with a gold-badge in the tag that marked your post as a duplicate. ...


8

No, they are not notified. That is unless you vote to close as a duplicate, or use a custom off-topic reason; those actions generate a comment and they are notified of comments. Note that users need to have 250 reputation to even see the close votes; other users do not notice them until their question is actually closed. If you're reasonably sure the ...


7

While I sympathise with the bona fide goals of your suggestion, I think it is too susceptible to abuse, and may excessively burden high-profile users. Consider the following thought experiments: OP sends dozens of flags to users who have no acquaintance with them Good-willing users flood high-profile users with a very large amount of "notifications" ...


7

Check your inbox: Like this: The number of unread messages will show up in red: (thanks to Daniel Fischer for providing the last image!)


7

Placing a bounty on a question will not directly notify a user that answered it. I am not convinced it is useful to inform the answerer again that you want a more detailed answer, but it would not be redundant with the bounty and not out-of-line either.


6

To complement robjohn's good answer let me just add that not rarely when it is used in fact it does not do anything as user use it in ways so that it will not result in a notification (or indeed will be redundant as you remarked). Very roughly, it can be used only to reply to users already in a communication not to call somebody into a communication. ...


6

In chat, the '@' symbol signals type-ahead for names and usually makes an audible ping on the recipient's computer as well as leaving a message in their inbox (the blue inbox icon next to "StackExchange"). In comments, the '@' symbol signals type-ahead for names and leaves a message in the recipient's inbox As Martin Sleziak comments, your global inbox is ...


6

The user Dustin, who is a nominee, in a comment, confirmed that pings are received.


5

If you are willing to get a somewhat enlarged range of notifications, you can subscribe to the RSS feed for that Question (this will notify you not only of edits to the Question, but new & edited Answers; however Comment activity does not appear to trigger notification). You'll need an RSS client, such as Google Reader, to receive such a feed. Even ...


5

EDIT: All possibilities mentioned here are superseded by possibility to follow posts implemented in April 2019. It is described in another answer. The original version of the answer (before this was implemented) is below. Let us try to summarize several possibilities how to follow question, which are mentioned in various answers and comments on this site: ...


5

I am slow and I get beat to an answer very often. I like getting points. They're fun. But I love mathematics. If someone beats me to an answer and his/hers is better than mine, I discard or delete mine. Of course there is a grey area there, and someone may object to my decision to post my answer too. To bad. I will gladly tell you why I disagree with you. My ...


5

My first post was quite recent, answering an OP that was about one and half years old. It got an immediate response which was quite gratifying and made me feel welcome on the site. However, my post was more of a comment, though I posted it as an answer, not knowing any better. Apparently I would not have bumped the question up to active if I'd followed the ...


4

I will share some of my thoughts. The main reason you run into these disagreements is, AFAICT, the following: Various users on our site hold wildly differing ideals of what they want the site to be like. This will then reflect on what kind of material they upvote, downvote, vote to close, vote to keep,... As a metaprinciple I think that for the site ...


4

This is probably because you already have more reputation on another site in the Stack Exchange network, and are supposed to 'know' that you can view close votes (on your own questions) at 250 reputation. The details are described in this Meta post but it's already six years old so I don't know if it's up to date (for instance, it doesn't show the new ...


4

You should be able to get to it from the "preferences" tab in your user profile. From there I believe you click on either "Manage filtered questions emails" or "advanced tag subscriptions".


4

A regression bug was introduced here that prevented some (but not all) comment notifications from going out. The issue has been fixed. Unfortunately there is no practical way for us to requeue the comment notifications that didn't get sent out in the past few hours.


3

First: I took a look at the question that you asked and that I assume that you are referring to. An aanswer was given, then you asked for a picture and I would think that you would have expected (or hoped for) the answer to be edited. So I am not sure that I understand how a notification would have benefited much. Second: That said, I would not oppose if ...


3

The answer has been deleted. Once you have earned 10K reputation (or been elected ♦-moderator), you'll be able to see it. (The other possibility is that the answer is undeleted at some point.)


Only top voted, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible