38
votes
Don't review a first question by simply downvoting it or voting to close it
Originally intended to be a comment, but I find that it is more of an answer than a comment.
I would suggest modifying the website to force newcomers to read the "Asking a good question" (...
- 1,441
31
votes
Accepted
Was this edit acceptable?
The idea behind rejecting an edit as it "[d]isguises the author's non-fluency in English" is others could take the fact that the poster is not fluent in English into account in their interactions. For ...
quidMod
- 41.9k
26
votes
Accepted
Rude and disrespectful behaviour - user complaining about deletion
Let me briefly answer your two questions, without dealing with the story around them.
When the situation is complex, avoid flagging comments. When we see a comment flag, it is easy to take it out of ...
- 390k
25
votes
Accepted
Five close votes is not enough to close a question?
Not all users actually had the close privilege thus there were not five votes to close even though the review-ticket lists more than five reviews with that recommendation.
Likely this distinction ...
quidMod
- 41.9k
23
votes
Accepted
The late answer review queue for "Late answers from new users"
I agree we should be encouraging for attempts by new users to tackle difficult (possibly unanswered) Questions, though these will more often appear in the First Posts review queue. A typical phrase I ...
- 36.6k
23
votes
Accepted
Non-human reviewer
When a user account gets deleted, some of its actions (votes, reviews, etc.) sometimes move to the Community account so they will not be nullified (sometimes we do want these to be nullified, in which ...
- 390k
21
votes
Accepted
Several users are gorging themselves in the Late Answer queue
The general sentiment is something that I share. In my mind the review queues are a good entry point for starting to get involved in community moderation and also to stay involved in it for somewhat ...
quidMod
- 41.9k
20
votes
Accepted
Why we need more than one review to accept an edit?
An experience I recently had might answer this.
I was so misled by a question title that I went ahead and spent half an hour writing an answer to the wrong thing, which I then had to discard.
So I ...
- 2,922
19
votes
Accepted
Whoa! 1300 items in the "Late answer" review queue
This is the result of a very recent change to the way answers enter that queue. Previously, the conditions were:
the answer was posted at least 30 days after the question was asked; and
the answer's ...
- 51.8k
19
votes
Accepted
"Strategy" for voting to close
A couple of points to consider:
It takes five votes to close any question.
If everyone saves their votes for some greater need, nothing gets closed.
Do your share and vote.
It's a community effort, ...
- 25.6k
18
votes
Accepted
Answer not deleted after six "Recommend Deletion"
Because the post has a positive score.
According to Shog9's answer on Is “recommend deletion” secretly a vote to delete?
Yes, a sufficient number of delete recommendations (currently 6 on most sites, ...
- 136
18
votes
Accepted
Why was this answer marked as "spam or offensive"?
I'd say the culprit is that last sentence:
This much anticipated second edition of the most successful calculus text published in the last two decades retains the best of the first edition while ...
- 240k
18
votes
Accepted
Link-only answers in LQQ
There has been no change to the software which would cause these answers to be automatically placed into a review queue.
The problem with link-only answers is that they are vulnerable to link-rot. ...
- 27.5k
16
votes
Accepted
Answer review - is it really answered question?
Ask the answerer in a comment to expand their answer a bit, and explain that the idea of the site is that in general an answer is not just a link or a reference to a source that gives an actual answer....
quidMod
- 41.9k
16
votes
The late answer review queue for "Late answers from new users"
I find myself being a newbie who answered a question long after the problem was debated. I thought on one hand that people will keep calling up that old issue and find a more versatile answer - I ...
- 383
15
votes
Accepted
Why is an answer not deleted even when all reviewers recommend deletion?
In this case the problem is that the score of the post is too high for being deleted in this form. The idea is that apparently there are some that find value in the contribution and so it maybe should ...
quidMod
- 41.9k
14
votes
Accepted
Another failed review audit for low quality posts
No, you did right. That's not an answer in any way, and voting to delete it is the correct action.
The poor audit system was misled by the post having a score of +5. Since it doesn't know any ...
- 205k
13
votes
Don't review a first question by simply downvoting it or voting to close it
I agree that the First Posts review queue calls upon Reviewers to do more than simply downvote and close. The instructions at the top of that page say:
This is the first question asked by a new user....
- 36.6k
12
votes
I'm reviewing many first posts by leaving a comment. Is it OK?
It appears to me that this is definitely behaviour in the spirit of the review system. Therefore you are definitely not doing something wrong.
If this were the Low Quality queue or the Close Votes ...
- 17.7k
11
votes
What are the guidelines for reviewing?
The site offers several review queues that make helping moderate this community more streamlined. For details on these queues, see the FAQ on Meta Stack Exchange: What are the review queues, and how ...
11
votes
Reviewing an answer that says the same thing as a comment?
The bad guy here is the comment. Comments are not supposed to be used for answers. It is very common to see answers in comments on this site and, as opposed to most other SE siblings, moderators here ...
- 202k
11
votes
Difficulty of getting review badges
I will point out that badges should be secondary, primary concern should be doing things that are useful for the site. So from this viewpoint, if you find the review queue empty, that's a good thing.
...
- 52.9k
11
votes
Accepted
What to do if the question says "I'm too tired..."
The best way to deal with this is to mentally remove this statement from the question. If the "modified" version merits a certain kind of vote, then cast it.
(By certain, I mean delete/close/up/down/...
- 390k
11
votes
Rude and disrespectful behaviour - user complaining about deletion
This case highlighted for me a limitation of the review queue process that might be worth bringing to the attention of the redesign project.
The Answer posted (and deleted from Review) was quite ...
- 36.6k
11
votes
Accepted
Earned Steward badge twice for the same queue
This is not a bug; it's part of an update to the review queues. You now get one Steward badge for every 1,000 reviews in a single queue. For more details, see Steward badge can now be awarded multiple ...
- 3,955
10
votes
Several users are gorging themselves in the Late Answer queue
From your question it seems that apart from the possibility to review in this queue, you also want to see the posts which went through the review.
Users with sufficient rep have access to the full ...
- 52.9k
Only top scored, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible