Return to Answer

Undeleted (still closed), Deleted, Undeleted, Deleted again, Undeleted again, and yet deleted again, and locked ("content dispute") by moderator Xander Henderson

The question What are sufficient conditions for a number to be irrational or transcendental? was closed as a duplicate of Proving irrationality and then deleted (along with answers with scores of $+12,+7,+4,+4$).

I suggest the newer question is not a duplicate of the older one. The newer question asks about proving irrationality, proving transcendence, and asks for books on these topics. The older question asks only about proving irrationality.

Please consider voting to undelete the question.

In the interests of full disclosure, I posted an answer to the question (scored $+2$).

Undeleted (still closed), Deleted, Undeleted, Deleted again, Undeleted again, and yet deleted again, and locked – permanently! – by moderator Xander Henderson

The question What are sufficient conditions for a number to be irrational or transcendental? was closed as a duplicate of Proving irrationality and then deleted (along with answers with scores of $+12,+7,+4,+4$).

I suggest the newer question is not a duplicate of the older one. The newer question asks about proving irrationality, proving transcendence, and asks for books on these topics. The older question asks only about proving irrationality.

Please consider voting to undelete the question.

In the interests of full disclosure, I posted an answer to the question (scored $+2$).

Undeleted (still closed), Deleted, Undeleted, Deleted again, Undeleted again, and yet deleted again

The question What are sufficient conditions for a number to be irrational or transcendental? was closed as a duplicate of Proving irrationality and then deleted (along with answers with scores of $+12,+7,+4,+4$).

I suggest the newer question is not a duplicate of the older one. The newer question asks about proving irrationality, proving transcendence, and asks for books on these topics. The older question asks only about proving irrationality.

Please consider voting to undelete the question.

In the interests of full disclosure, I posted an answer to the question (scored $+2$).

Undeleted (still closed), Deleted, Undeleted, Deleted again, Undeleted again, and yet deleted again, and locked ("content dispute") by moderator Xander Henderson

The question What are sufficient conditions for a number to be irrational or transcendental? was closed as a duplicate of Proving irrationality and then deleted (along with answers with scores of $+12,+7,+4,+4$).

I suggest the newer question is not a duplicate of the older one. The newer question asks about proving irrationality, proving transcendence, and asks for books on these topics. The older question asks only about proving irrationality.

Please consider voting to undelete the question.

In the interests of full disclosure, I posted an answer to the question (scored $+2$).

Undeleted (still closed), Deleted, Undeleted, Deleted again, Undeleted again...

The question What are sufficient conditions for a number to be irrational or transcendental? was closed as a duplicate of Proving irrationality and then deleted (along with answers with scores of $+12,+7,+4,+4$).

I suggest the newer question is not a duplicate of the older one. The newer question asks about proving irrationality, proving transcendence, and asks for books on these topics. The older question asks only about proving irrationality.

Please consider voting to undelete the question.

In the interests of full disclosure, I posted an answer to the question (scored $+2$).

Undeleted (still closed), Deleted, Undeleted, Deleted again, Undeleted again, and yet deleted again

The question What are sufficient conditions for a number to be irrational or transcendental? was closed as a duplicate of Proving irrationality and then deleted (along with answers with scores of $+12,+7,+4,+4$).

I suggest the newer question is not a duplicate of the older one. The newer question asks about proving irrationality, proving transcendence, and asks for books on these topics. The older question asks only about proving irrationality.

Please consider voting to undelete the question.

In the interests of full disclosure, I posted an answer to the question (scored $+2$).