Recently, this question was asked on math.SE. I had originally thought the subject was the definition of the modulus $ | \cdot | : \mathbb{C} \to \mathbb{R^+} $, so I posted the shortcut for solving the equation as a comment so as not to be accused of not answering the question as has happened to others before.

When it was posted as an answer, I was surprised that didn't happen; at the risk of sounding petty, I somewhat regret fearing downvotes and not doing so myself, given the answer's overwhelming (favorable) reception. Upon reading the original post and first answers again, however, it seems not to match what the asker intended; though useful to know, such a reply doesn't really address the question itself. (I may very well be wrong about this, but that was my impression.)

When is it acceptable to post information or thoughts that are only related to a question rather than direct answers? I very much enjoy this site and would like to post more often, but it's difficult to get started here or anywhere when you keep holding back until you're confident both that your answer is correct and that it won't be considered inappropriate or not what one was looking for.


1 Answer 1


If the answer is an honest attempt to either answer the question or provide some kind of relevant background and/or context, I think it's fine. Additionally, sometimes a question is hard and you have an idea which you're not sure works; depending on how well-formed it is, you might want to post this either as a comment or as a CW answer.


You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .